A borrower can move up or down twenty to forty points depending on which credit model is used. That is not a rumor. It is the credit shift, and it is one of the biggest things most mortgage leaders are not talking about yet.
After more than two decades in this business, I have watched scoring models quietly rewrite who gets approved and who does not. If you lead a lending team, this shift is not a compliance footnote. It is a competitive advantage.
What Is the Credit Shift?
The mortgage industry is moving away from decades of relying on one mandated credit model, Classic FICO, toward three approved models: Classic FICO, VantageScore 4.0, and FICO Score 10T. That change was set in motion by the Credit Score Competition Act of 2018, and the Federal Housing Finance Agency validated FICO 10T and VantageScore 4.0 for use by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in October 2022.
The real technical change is trended data. The new models analyze twenty-four months of payment patterns instead of a point-in-time snapshot, and they can incorporate rent, utility, and telecom payments when those are reported. For a borrower who has spent two years paying down balances, that history can translate into a meaningful score gain. It can also bring people into the scoring pool who were previously unscoreable.
What Has Actually Changed
The timeline matters, because it tells you where the market is going. In July 2025, the FHFA made VantageScore 4.0 available immediately for all Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgages. In April 2026, the agencies updated their Selling Guides to permit VantageScore 4.0 right away and future FICO 10T, and HUD approved both models for FHA-insured underwriting. By September 2026, VantageScore 4.0 expanded to all approved lenders without prior written approval.
FICO 10T full GSE delivery is still pending, but the adoption program passed seventy mortgage lenders by mid-2026. The direction is clear. This is not a someday shift. It is happening now.
The Leader's Move
Here is the trap most teams will fall into: treating the credit shift as a back-office technicality. The leaders who win will treat it as a pipeline expansion.
- Coach to the whole file, not the top-line score. When a borrower looks marginal on Classic FICO, the trended models can tell a different story. The team that understands the full picture stops turning away loans the market is opening up.
- Retrain the scripts, not just the system. Your originators should be able to explain what a trended score means and when a borrower benefits from it. Knowledge is what separates an order-taker from an advisor.
- Update the marketing conversation. If your messaging still targets the borrower of last cycle, you are marketing to yesterday. The borrower pool is changing shape under you.
- Build the referral engine now. The lenders who understand the models will win the borrowers other teams turn away, and those borrowers will remember who said yes.
The Xactus Conversation
I brought Shelley Leonard and Greg Holmes of Xactus onto Talking Shift with Craig for an episode we called “The Credit Shift: The Truth, The Strategies, The Win.” We walked through the changing credit-reporting market and what it means for lenders on the ground. It is a great place to start if you want the mechanics behind the headlines.
When leaders understand the mechanics behind the approval, they stop reacting to rate news and start building strategy.
Catch every episode of Talking Shift with Craig on Apple Podcasts and on YouTube, and follow the conversation on LinkedIn and Instagram.
Make Shift Happen.
The Build Your Niche Takeaway
The same discipline that turns the credit shift into an advantage is the reason to Build Your Niche. When you know your niche, your purpose, and your ideal customer, you stop selling the commodity and start solving the problem, the way The Rise of the Travel Agent and The 25 Basis Point Margin show. Book your Build Your Niche Huddle below and build your niche on purpose.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the credit shift in mortgage lending?
It is the industry's move away from relying on one mandated credit model, Classic FICO, toward three approved models: Classic FICO, VantageScore 4.0, and FICO Score 10T. The models use 24 months of trended payment data and can incorporate rent, utility, and telecom payments, which can lift scores for borrowers who have paid down balances and bring previously unscoreable consumers into the pool.
When did the new credit scoring models become available?
The FHFA validated FICO 10T and VantageScore 4.0 in October 2022. VantageScore 4.0 became available for all Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgages in July 2025, the agencies and FHA approved it in April 2026, and it expanded to all approved lenders in September 2026. Full FICO 10T GSE delivery is still pending, with 70+ lenders already in the adoption program.
What should loan officers do to prepare for the credit shift?
Coach to the whole file, not just the top-line score, and learn how trended data can tell a different story for a marginal borrower. Retrain your scripts so originators can explain what a trended score means, update your marketing for the changing borrower pool, and build your referral engine now. Understanding the models is a competitive advantage.
Why does Craig Davis understand the mortgage business?
Twenty years in the mortgage business, building teams, merging companies, running P&Ls, and knowing what decisions with consequences mean. I know margins, profitability, and what it takes to lead a lending team through a market shift, because I have done it.
This is part of the Build Your Niche Framework: Know Your Niche.
Craig Davis is a Leadership Performance Coach, keynote speaker, and creator of the Build Your Niche Framework. He is Craig Davis, Leadership Performance Coach at Ascend Xperience Coaching & Consulting and host of the Talking Shift podcast, with 20+ years in sales and leadership in the mortgage industry.
Craig is an amazing coach. He has worked directly with us as well as worked with our team and we cannot speak highly enough of him, and the impact he has had on our team.
THE MORTGAGE DR