Choosing an executive coach is a decision most leaders make once, badly, and then swear off coaching for a decade. I want you to make it well. I am Craig Davis, a Leadership Performance Coach with twenty years inside the mortgage business, and this is exactly what I tell executives when they ask how they should have vetted the coaches they hired before me.
What Executives Say Before They Call
Every first conversation I have starts with the same three needs. I need a coach who will help me execute, not just make me feel better. I need a coach with real experience, who has done the work, not read about it. And I need someone who understands what I do: margins, P&Ls, rate cycles, teams, mergers, and how a production calendar actually breathes.
Those three needs are the right test to put any coach through. Most coaching relationships fail before the first session, because the leader picked a smart person with a nice methodology instead of the right person for the job.
The Trap: A Coach Who Learned Mortgage From a Newsletter
A generic coach can give you great frameworks and zero context. Mortgage is not a soft business. It is a margin business measured in basis points, staffed by people who feel every rate headline, and led by executives who cannot say the quiet part to their own team. A coach who has never run a P&L will coach you on what leadership looked like in someone else's industry.
When I work with mortgage executives, I bring the technical background: twenty years of sales and leadership, P&Ls, margins, profitability, building teams, merging companies, creating partnerships and ending some amicably, building things and tearing them down, failing forward. I have made decisions with consequences, and I can say the quiet part out loud because I have lived it.
What to Look For
- They have lived your kind of pressure. Strategy is easy to read about. Shared pain is not. A coach who has carried a P&L and kept a team together through a rate spike will ask better questions than one who has only read case studies.
- They ask questions before they give answers. You already have answers. The job is to find the blind ones. If a coach hands you a script in the first call, that is not coaching, that is selling.
- They break your echo chamber. The highest-paid person in the room gets the least honest feedback. Your team is not going to tell you the strategy is tired. Your coach has to, kindly and clearly.
- They push execution, not just insight. Insight without action is a conversation. A good coach holds you accountable to the plan you built, in your words, against the calendar you set.
- They have done their own work. A coach who has never been coached is a red flag. The people I stay close to all work with someone, and most of them have moved through a hard chapter of their own.
Questions to Ask Before You Commit
- What does help me execute mean in a typical session?
- How will we measure progress at 30, 60, and 90 days?
- What happens when I disagree with your advice?
- Who else have you coached in or around mortgage, and what changed?
- Tell me about a time you failed forward.
Honest answers to those five questions will tell you more than any credential. The first one is the most important. If the coach cannot describe what execution looks like session by session, keep interviewing.
See the Play on the Podcast
Alan Mack joined me on Talking Shift with Craig this summer, in the episode we called Building the Luxury Niche. He left big-bank red tape behind, built a luxury and complex-deal niche as an independent financing advisor, and stopped specializing in product. He started specializing in humans, and the business showed up. That is coached thinking in action: same market, different lane.
The deeper research on whether coaching works lives in Executive Coaching for Mortgage Leaders, and the isolation problem is unpacked in Breaking the Echo Chamber.
When It's Time
The life events that should trigger the call are predictable: a leadership change, a company change, feeling stuck in a business you built, or a problem you can feel but cannot name. If you are waiting for permission, this is it.
Keep the conversation going between sessions. Catch every episode of Talking Shift with Craig on Apple Podcasts and on YouTube, and follow the daily conversation on LinkedIn and Instagram.
Make Shift Happen.
Sources
- Talking Shift with Craig on Apple Podcasts
- Stanford GSB and The Miles Group: Executive Coaching Survey
- ICF Coaching Statistics and Industry Insights
The Build Your Niche Takeaway
You will choose a coach the way you choose a niche: on clarity. The same filters, have they lived the pressure, will they break the echo chamber, do they push execution, are the filters for building your niche and the system for success that follows. Put them to work on the coach and on the business at the same time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes an executive coach qualified to work with mortgage leaders?
Operating experience. Craig Davis brings twenty years in the mortgage business, P&Ls, margins, profitability, building teams, merging companies, and creating and ending partnerships. A coach who has lived the margin pressure asks better questions than one who has only read about it.
How is executive coaching different from consulting?
A consultant delivers a report. A coach builds the strategy with you, stretches your thinking, and holds you accountable for executing it. With Craig, the client owns the plan and the calendar, which is why execution actually happens.
How quickly should I expect results from executive coaching?
Expect structure first. Coaching sets 30, 60, and 90 day execution targets, and momentum shows up when you hit the first honest milestone. Motivation fades in days; momentum compounds from a system, which is why Craig coaches for systems, not pep talks.
Can executive coaching help with stress?
Yes, in a practical way. Stress does not drop because the job got easier. It drops when strategy is clear and you stop carrying it alone. For a deeper look, read A Stress Mitigation Playbook for Leaders.
This is part of the Build Your Niche Framework: Know Your Niche, Grow Your Niche.
Craig Davis is a Leadership Performance Coach, keynote speaker, and creator of the Build Your Niche Framework. He is Craig Davis, Leadership Performance Coach at Ascend Xperience Coaching & Consulting and host of the Talking Shift podcast, with 20+ years in sales and leadership in the mortgage industry.
I had the privilege to have a consultation with Craig Davis and was blown away. He spoke on my level while leveling me up. I am thrilled with the way he motivates, encourages and drives. Highly recommend him and his company!
Mark B.